October 29, 2026
The tents at Tin City came down Sunday evening. For three days the Naples Stone Crab Festival filled 1200 Fifth Avenue South with live music, arts and crafts vendors, barbecue from Texas Tony's and claws in several sizes. It ran from Friday, October 23, through Sunday, October 25, it was the festival's 16th year, and admission was free.
The festival is the loudest weekend of stone crab season, but it came just eight days after the opener. The 2026-27 season opened October 15 and runs through May 1, so from Royal Harbor, the claws across the bay are available for six more months. The bigger story this year is the price. Crabbers started the season with fuel bills about twice what they paid last year, yet the opening-week price reports show claws costing about what they cost a year ago. The crabbers are carrying the extra fuel cost, and diners mostly aren't seeing it.
In Everglades City, the stone crab fleet started its season with a tradition. On a Saturday before the opener, the Florida Stone Crabbers Association held its annual Blessing of the Fleet at Camellia Street Grill. That tradition is now 17 years old. As WINK News reported, families walked from boat to boat while local faith leaders prayed over each one, and the day included a guava cake competition and a mullet toss.
The outlook from the docks was hopeful. Kelly Kirk of the association told WINK, "We've had a beautiful summer. No big storms. The water quality is outstanding right now." Commercial fisherman Macbeth "Mackie" Collins has been stone crabbing for more than 30 years and is a third-generation crabber. He told the station he expected "a pretty good season" in terms of production.
That calm summer had one interruption before the opener. Hurricane Isaias made landfall near Destin on the evening of October 9 according to the National Hurricane Center, and the Naples Daily News reported it came ashore as a Category 2 hurricane in the Florida Panhandle. NBC2 said that day that the storm posed no direct threat to Southwest Florida and might bring rough surf and passing downpours. WINK's forecast called for 3- to 6-foot Gulf waves and tides less than a foot above normal. The season opened on schedule six days later.
Collins's biggest worry wasn't the catch. It was diesel.
"From what I'm seeing, our fuel costs are double from what we started at last year. It just cuts into our profit."
He also told WINK that crabbers can't always pass that cost on. "I wish I could, but other people tell me what they're going to give us for them," he said. "That's just how it is."
The crabber pays the fuel bill, but the buyer sets the price. The first price reports of the season show where that leaves the plate price. On October 19, 2026, the South Florida Sun Sentinel surveyed wholesalers and fish markets on the state's east coast. They reported strong opening hauls, steady demand, and prices flat with the start of last season, apart from some shortages of medium claws in the first days. These are Broward and Palm Beach area prices, not Naples prices. Still, they are the clearest opening-week benchmark for 2026:
| Claw size | Low-overhead wholesaler, per pound | Boutique wholesaler, per pound |
|---|---|---|
| Medium | $22 | $39 |
| Large | $32 | $49 |
| Jumbo | $45 | $69 |
| Colossal | $50 | $79 |
The two columns differ in overhead, not catch. The first seller works from a refrigerated van with no storefront. The second runs a boutique wholesale shop, and its owner said his prices are about even with last season. He also told the Sun Sentinel that diesel is what keeps prices from dropping. "If fuel prices stay high, the prices will stay the same," he said. Prices would fall, in his view, only if production outran demand and the extra claws went into freezers.
So a good harvest isn't lowering the price of claws this season. Fuel is holding prices up, demand is holding them steady, and by Collins's account, crabbers like him are absorbing the gap between the two.
Two of the names tied to stone crab this season sit on Fifth Avenue South, just across the water from Royal Harbor, and a third is at the docks in Everglades City:
Kelly's Fish House Dining Room, 1302 Fifth Avenue South. It sits on the Gordon River, and its website advertises fresh-caught stone crabs from "October 15 thru May 1." The site doesn't post a 2026-27 price or say how much it has in stock, so a call before driving over is the reliable way to find out what's on hand that night.
Pinchers at Tin City, 1200 Fifth Avenue South. The festival host worked with local crab trappers to bring in thousands of stone crabs for last weekend, according to WINK. On the regular Tin City menu, the $25 "Pinchers Claws" are fresh blue crab claws, not stone crab, so it pays to ask whether stone crab is available before ordering.
City Seafood, 702 Begonia Street, Everglades City. This is the drive to the source. City Seafood's website says its market sells stone crabs caught by its own boats. No price is posted, so call ahead to check availability and size before you make the trip.
Weekly availability by claw size is the one thing none of these three posts online, and the Sun Sentinel's report of opening-week medium shortages suggests it's worth asking about.
For Royal Harbor households with a boat at the seawall, the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission's stone crab page lists the recreational harvest season in state waters as October 15 through May 1, with May 2 closed. Only claws may be harvested, and the minimum claw size is 2 7/8 inches. The Sun Sentinel noted that the FWC shortened the season by two weeks in 2020, moving the closing date from May 15 to May 1 to curb overfishing and give crabs time to regrow their claws. The FWC page is the place to read the full rules and check for any updates before setting a trap. This is general information, not legal advice, so confirm your own situation with the agency directly.
The May 1 closing date also sets the calendar on the restaurant side. Pinchers' marketing and advertising director, Kevin Rooney, made that point to WINK last week. "Stone crab season is only available for a short period of time, so you're going to want to get your hands on some stone crabs while you can," he said. This year, the festival also supported Honor Flight, which helps American veterans visit the memorials in Washington, D.C., and attendees could contribute through donations and a silent auction.
The Everglades City fleet went out expecting a strong catch and fuel bills twice last year's. Opening-week price reports from the state's east coast showed claws selling for about what they cost a year ago, and the season runs through May 1.
At SWFL Navarro Group, we keep track of the small seasonal calendars that shape life on Naples Bay, from the October 15 opener to the May 1 close. If you're new to the canals of Royal Harbor or have been here for years and want a local recommendation in English or Spanish, our family would be glad to help. Find Your Dream Home Today.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
We pride ourselves in providing personalized solutions that bring our clients closer to their dream properties and enhance their long-term wealth. Contact us for an experience that moves you!